
I’ve been reading Bart D. Ehrman’s latest book, Love Thy Stranger, in which he makes the case that Jesus’ introduced a far more encompassing morality than existed in the Judeo-Greco-Roman world in which he lived. This new morality extended well beyond the confines of the tribe or community of the previous moral codes of Judaism and Greek civilisation and embraced the stranger, the poor and the needy. Ehrman makes the case that Jesus introduced altruism to the world as the greatest form of morality, with consequences that reach down to the present.
I’ll leave it you to decide whether this is the case. The book is worth reading and raised a few other interesting points. First, Ehrman assumes that Jesus’ admonition to love your neighbour and his insistence that those with wealth should divest themselves of it to provide for the poor are the actual words of Jesus. He seems to think they were somehow captured verbatim by the gospel writers, which seems to contradict his argument in Jesus Before the Gospels that the so-called oral tradition is unreliable.
You may, like me, have your doubts about this assumption. Ehrman makes a strong case however that they are: the morality of the early church, as we know from Paul’s writing, did not extend to caring for the stranger. Paul always talks about helping the poor within and across the early Christian communities themselves, in keeping with the Greco-priorities of the time. He speaks too of helping those in need from the surplus held by each church and its members, with no mention of selling everything to give to the poor in general. Ehrman argues that is unlikely that such communities would then invent speeches for their Saviour that espouse a different kind of morality, that proposed giving everything away. If however these communities did not know of these principles – and Paul himself appears not to – then perhaps that is what the next generation of believers, those that existed when the gospels were written, actually did. Who knows.
Where therefore do such radical idea come from if not Jesus himself? It’s a good question (and one absent as far as I can remember from Ehrman’s ‘proofs’ in Did Jesus Exist? that Jesus was a real person). Why would early church communities invent speech for their hero that promoted values that bore little relation to their own?
The communities that produced the synoptic gospels could of course have been different from those Paul addresses. They could have been the kind that prioritised the poor and needy outside their communities as well as within. It could also be the case that churches established after Paul (writing between 55 and 64) and having nothing to do with him, developed more of a social conscience than those in Rome, Thessalonica or Corinth. It’s possible, but unlikely; unlikely that the records we have of early church morality (the seven Paul addresses) are the very ones that didn’t subscribe to Jesus’ extreme view of giving. Perhaps though they came to see helping the poor as a means of converting them to the Christian cause. But that really wouldn’t be the kind of altruism Jesus appears to espouse.
Equally, what are we to make of the situation in which the churches Paul did address appear not to know that Jesus promoted benevolence to the poor in general? Perhaps he didn’t. Early Christians are known to have referred to themselves as The Poor (‘Ebionites’, a Jewish Christian sect that survived until the early 5th century) and certainly the majority of them would have been, existing on the subsistence line. It’s possible then that when Jesus is made to refer to the poor in the gospels he doesn’t mean the general poor at all, but to The Poor: Impoverished church members themselves. The coded message in the gospels, starting with Mark 10:17-22, could be a form of emotional blackmail, compelling wealthier church members to give what they have to help their poorer brethren.
If this doesn’t seem plausible (though I think it is, and probable too) then the question of why early churches, such as the seven we knew about from Paul, so quickly abandoned Jesus’ altruistic demands once he died? Ehrman has his theories, and relates the reinterpretation of the commands to help the stranger and the poor to that of salvation, different in the gospels from that preached by Paul and his successors. I’ll get to this next time.