Hysteria/Mission Creep/Overreach

When I was head (principal) of a primary (elementary) school in the 1990s, I had a staff member who regarded every small problem as ‘a Major Disaster’ (her words). Everything from a mislaid document to wet weather on sports day was an earth-shattering calamity. She was not the only one to overstate manageable events. Those who wield authority over us, their media lackeys and those with a cause of their own to promote are expert in whipping the populace up into a frenzy disproportionate to the given situation. After a short period in the spotlight, the hysteria and the movements that cause it usually fade, as the media finds something newer and shinier about which to induce panic. Occasionally, the newly out-of-favour movements fight back with renewed vigour, a mission creep extending their influence into new areas.

Looking back over the last 25 years, I and my fellow citizens here in the UK have been expected to be alarmed to an alarming degree about:

The Millennium Bug, when every computer in the world, so the experts said, would crash the instant the year 2000 started. This would, in turn, crash every automated system everywhere, causing chaos and mass fatalities. You all know what actually happened.

Foot & Mouth Disease, when millions of cattle and sheep were slaughtered and burnt. Millions of healthy animals were destroyed in case they contracted the disease.

Weapons of Mass Destruction supposedly amassed by Iraq who, we were told, could unleash them on the West within 45 minutes. That there was no evidence of any WMDs and the fact Iraq did not deploy them (because you can’t deploy something that doesn’t exist) did not deter George W. Bush and Tony Blair from launching their oxymoronic (with the emphasis on the moronic) ‘war on terror’. In so doing, they destabilised the world, creating many of the problems we face today.

Child Abuse Scandals: After either missing or covering up the serial abuse of children and vulnerable people by a BBC celebrity, British authorities went to town on ‘suspected paedophiles’, many of whom were nothing of the sort. (A friend of mine was caught up in this hysteria and spent time in prison for a youthful indiscretion many years earlier.) Unfortunately, this national crisis and the perceived need not to offend Muslims came into conflict when, over 20 years, rape gangs comprised mainly of Pakistani men were able operate in up to 50 UK cities with impunity. Hundreds of thousands of vulnerable, white working-class girls were systematically groomed and raped while the police and authorities turned a blind eye, the consequence of a woke priority taking precedence over the rights and safety of others.     

The Covid Pandemic and Lockdown, when governments the world over (apart from Sweden) panicked about a flu-like virus, closed down entire countries, failed to protect the vulnerable and crashed the very economies needed to fund healthcare and treatment for the infected. Britain was closed down for almost 2 years and still hasn’t recovered from the consequences. Citizens are now paying heavily for actions taken by a government that extended its powers to achieve very little.

        Cartoon by Mark Woods, Spectator magazine, 7th June '25

Mental Health issues and the medicalised labelling of ordinary human behaviours. We all have mental health issues; this is what it is to be human. Some, it is true, have more than others. Determining an individual has ‘mental health issues’ forces him or her to become his or her issues. Instead of being prone to depression (as I was) or anxiety, the individual who experiences these is now ‘neuro-diverse’. Instead of suffering from a condition the individual could do something about they become that condition. Some people, usually males, used to be diagnosed as autistic. Now that autism is seen as a spectrum, everyone is deemed to be on it somewhere; everyone as a result is autistic. People become trapped in their condition with no way out, lifelong treatment the only recourse.

Black Lives Matter. As Lionel Shriver asks here, do black lives matter any more now than they did before all that righteous indignation and virtual signalling from white people?

Identity Politics in which individuals were told as a matter of urgency to self-identify solely on the basis of their ethnicity, religion, gender or sexuality. Gender dysphoria became a thing from which the trans-movement emerged. While I’ve every sympathy for those who feel they were born in the wrong body, society was unprepared for and incapable of dealing with the consequences. Women became ‘cis-women’, sex became ‘gender’ (a grammatical term), ‘non-binary’ became an option and the abuse of pronouns was politicised. An individual could identify as a plural ‘they’, while others lost their jobs if they declined to play along. Worst of all, children, who were too young to be allowed a tattoo, were given puberty blocking drugs, and in some cases surgery, because they felt they were the wrong sex. Children.

The High Court in the UK recently ruled that a man cannot become a woman, entrenching the views of campaigners and prompting other supporters to claim they knew this all along.

Wokeism; while it’s right and proper to treat each other with kindness, courtesy and consideration, politicising something we were, by and large, already doing was not. Wokeism pushed the boundaries over what could be done or said, or rather could not. Anything that might cause someone else offence was forbidden; commenting or criticising others’ religious beliefs or defending women’s rights became ‘hateful’; having a view on unsustainable immigration numbers made you a fascist. This was the era of cancelling those who did not conform to woke ideals. Toppling statues was popular too on the basis that a long-forgotten figure from 250 years ago may have had a slight connection with the slave trade. Western guilt for actions over which people living today had no part in and demands for reparations to those equally uninvolved ensued.

The ‘necessary’ control of free speech, a panic we’re still mired in. Stupid and inflammatory comments on social media can now earn you a prison sentence longer than that of a paedophile offender, often preceded by a visit from half a dozen policemen who will root through your house looking for evidence that you might have once had a ‘Brexity’ thought. Subjects off limits are; arguing that Covid19 began in a Wuhan laboratory (it might upset the Chinese); Islam, Islamic extremism and the Pro-Palestinian movement (however it’s still okay to criticise and condemn Jewish people for the actions of their government); expressing views different from the UK government’s and whatever the prevailing narrative happens to be. A government agency, ‘Prevent‘, last year redefined terrorism (see below) as ‘vocal support of ideologies that advocate discrimination’ and any expression of what it calls ‘cultural nationalism’. What this means is that those who call out religiously-motivated discrimination, lawlessness and terrorism are to be considered terrorists themselves. Actual terrorism and violence is therefore protected against those who would speak out about it, those who do so being the real terrorists. To put it another way, which I read recently (though can’t remember where): those who say hurty things are far more culpable than those who commit actual hurty things. This Orwellian doublespeak must now be taught in universities and other higher education institutions.  

The Climate Crisis and Net-Zero. You must be alarmed by the climate crisis (see here for how much of it Al Gore got wrong). You must too pay heavily for net-zero, thanks to additional taxes; energy prices in the UK are the highest in the world. You must buy into the government’s attempts to enforce a net-zero energy policy by 2050, despite net-zero being unachievable.

What if, might, could, maybe: the media’s favourite phrases to ramp up hysteria. ‘There might be terrible consequences’; ‘we could be headed for another Major Disaster’; ‘if X happens (though it hasn’t) then Y could possibly follow.’ When did the media stop reporting what has actually happened and take up fortune telling instead?  

* * * * * *

There is some comfort in the fact that the so-called crises and hysteria of the past eventually receded and faded away. So too will many of these current causes. All things, as George Harrison once wisely reminded us, must pass. They will, however, be replaced by others equally irrational and preposterous. Those who create them, be they governments, special interest groups or overwrought Swedish teenagers will expect us to conform to their Chicken-Little levels of hysteria. When they do, don’t be alarmed and be sure to seek out the evidence for yourself.

4 thoughts on “Hysteria/Mission Creep/Overreach

  1. Agreed, there is a marketting logic for the media to sell scandals. I guess that is one of the downsides of commercial culture. I must say though, that I see your examples in a bit of a different light.

    All the actual experts I knew at the time laughed off the Millenium bug and in any responsible media reflected upon the issue as not likely to be a real threat.

    I wonder, if the precursions had not been taken and the foot and mouth disease had taken a turn to a catastrophy, what would your take on it be now? The danger appeared as real enough, but even if it had not been, some risks are just not worth taking. Thinking safety belts must be futile, because I did not crash in traffic today, is kind of redundand.

    The lie about the weapons of mass destruction was concocted in the wake of the big Islamophobic scare of 9/11. It served as an excuse for vengeance of the frightened Western populations. Osama bin Laden achieved his goal to cause a war between the secular West and Islamic nations, because he was worried about secularisation leaking into his world through increased interaction between different cultures. It is up to us to not promote his agenda. Is it not?

    Pedophilia claims made in the social media and grown into popular conspiracy theories, back in the US had a severe effect on elections, the political culture and at least one pizza restaurant. Blaming the inability of the police department to catch rapists on how they tolerated Muslim religious culture, is like saying that they should have had at least one racist cop there. Funny. “Youthfull indiscretion”???

    Before using Sweden as an example of what happened during the pandemic, perhaps you should first find out what happened there. The Swedish medical officials (headed by Andreas Tegnell) issued no lockdowns, because they trusted that the Swedes as an educated nation would follow the recommendations issued on their own volition untill herd immunity could be established through vaccinations and cases of infections. This tactic failed and the death toll was in serious rise when they started to follow suite with other EU countries on lockdowns. There was no panic in Tanzanian government, their president claimed prayer granted sufficient protection just prior to his own death by COVID-19.

    Today we have far better diagnostics and medication to actual mental health issues previously clumped and stigmatised. People do get help. Especially in countries with functioning universal healthcare.

    BLM is to be seen as only a step in an age old fight for justice and more precisely racism. If it was possible to predict with absolute certainty wich particular battles are going to be won and be great victories, then such struggles would not drag on for generations. Some battles are important even if they end in defeats, or would you not agree?

    Sex refers to biology. Gender refers to social construct built around sex. Of course puberty blockers are given to children and have been for decades, mostly not in relation to any gender issues. They are medication designed for children. Blocking puberty in an adult would be too late. Because we were not created as the perfect images of a god, but are biological enteties, we sometimes may make our lives better through medication. For some reason plastic surgery on under aged seems only to reach scandal levels if it is done to change sex. It has been turned into a political tool for the extreme conservatives.

    All the scandal around anything labelled as woke seems to come from the right. Mostly comprising of social media rumours. I recently saw a video of a woman disturbed by a duck “raping” a nother. It was labelled as “woke hysteria” while there was nothing tieing the woman as woke. Unless the person who published it wanted to say she must be woke, because she is against rape, and woke people are crazy enough to deny it even from animals. What do you think?

    Freedom of speech is an important liberty, but it is never absolute and there is such things as slander and hate speech, of wich we have ample examples and serious reprecussions. Is it not curious, how Trump whose followers have cried for free speech, have now started a campaign in international universities against the use of certain words, like for example gender and climate change?

    Speaking of wich, the climate change is a very real and serious threat. This is pretty much the consensus of the actual experts in the field. I am sorry that you feel bad for being forced to sacrifice for the future generations, but the reality owes nothing to your discomfort.

    You must be an intelligent person to have renounced your religious indoctrination. I bet you will also be able to brake the spell of the right-wing rabbit hole you appear to have fallen.

    Like

      • Ah, what a relief to hear. It was just that since Nan had liked some of your posts, I thought I should check out if you were being sarcastic, or not. You addressed so many talking points of the extreme right-wing conspiracy theorists, that I thought I should point out some their weaknesses just for the record. Of course, it is true, that these days sarcasm is growing ever harder to recognize, as the Trump era has brought insane nonsense to the political field. In addition because English is not my native tongue, such nyances as with sarcasm often bypass me. Even so, I sometimes dabble with sarcasm, though I really should not.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.